well a total rip off from the tamil one as i have heard from lots of people who have seen the tamil version of ghajini. The first 10 minutes i was totally lost on understanding whats happening and why? no clue just an abrupt start ... then suddenly things fall into line ... the knitting in the initial part is very loose ..... music is good .... asin seems to look like arti chhabria in some parts .. otherwise she is good but way to go to be super actress in bollywood for this sandalwood queen. For me its an average attempt from Amir Khan keeping in mind the kind of movies he has made and acted.