'Hum Tumhare Hain Sanam' was a disaster in big cities but did well in rural areas and small towns. It's not hard to see why. The film is way way way over the top! Every line of dialouge is practically screamed out and the histrionics are at a fever-pitch. This makes for very uncomfortable viewing. The script is clichéd and fifteen minutes into the film, it's possible to guess the complete story.
Shahrukh Khan overacts with a vengeance and makes his role a caricature. His scenes with Madhuri tend to grate. Madhuri Dixit and Salman Khan acted well but the scenes and situations are not like the taste of viewers. And Aishwarya was so annoying in the film. No doubt she is a beautiful and wonderful actress in the industry, but I guess this would be her most pathetic movie in her career.
The music by Bappi Lehri was also disturbing. One song by Nikhil Vinay "sub kuch bhula diya' was somewhat nice.
All in all, A flawed script & Best avoided.