An interesting "twist" of a movie for sure.. I personally was not impressed with Pritam's music ..
Saif has definitely come of age.. I felt he has carried the movie very well.. Deepika on the other hand is certainly the best looking hottest woman on screen today.. but she CANNOT ACT to save her life!!!
I found the Rishi Kapoor angle the best part of the movie. Keeping things sane and sweet.
All said and done, somewhere through the movie I felt that Imtiaz Ali has a way of doing ordinary things in a special way and thus making the product an extraordinary one. Yes, there are tricks he needs to learn, and with experience he might. But, then if he falls into the bollywood traps - we will lose a fine director. I felt right through the movie a lack of consistency that made me sit up and laugh at times, while letting me go into a bored stupor at others.. thankfully, he has kept it short at 2hr 15 mins .. so the torture was limited...