Let me start of by saying that I am a huge fan of Onir. Bas ek Pal is my all time favorite. So if i give 3/5 to his movie, its given that there is a flaw in the movie. And the flaw is the climax. The entire series of twists and turns (characterisitic of Onir) that preceded the climax deserved a better treatment. Infact its not a climax at all. Its so poor, you almost feel cheated.
The chemistry between Shabana and Bomman is pretty good. Chitrangada is hot and sizzling. She characterises the dilemma that all of Onir's heroines have... remember Urmila in Bas Ek Pal.
Another weak point is the music. Well its not bad. But it doesnt carry the movie at any stage. There is no superhit song in the movie. Sharman and Sanjay are allright. It's just that when you sit for a movie for over two hours and are left quenching for that little bit extra at the end, thats what drives me mad. I mean its not a bad movie by any stretch but I just hate movies that have poor climax, and this takes the cake for that!!!